Texas Plastic Surgeon is Accused of Paying $9,000 in Gold Bars for Killing of Love Rival

Plots about wealthy people planning the deaths of love rivals feature heavily in TV crime shows but are rare in real life.

Many homicides involve people who know each other and many are spontaneous rather than meticulously planned.

However a case in Lubbock, Texas in which a plastic surgeon is accused of paying an alleged hit man $9,000 to kill a doctor who was dating his ex-girlfriend, has made national headlines.

The payment was in three gold bars, each valued at about $3,000, say prosecutors.

Dr. Thomas Michael Dixon and David Neal Shepard were arrested by police in Amarillo in July, the Huffington Post reported. They are suspected of being involved in the death of Lubbock doctor Dr. Joseph Sonnier III.

“An arrest warrant affidavit suggests a love triangle between Dixon, Sonnier and a woman who was not identified by police,” the Huffington Post stated.

The affidavit claimed Dixon offered Shepard the three bars, each valued at $3,000, to kill Sonnier, who was the chief pathologist for Covenant Health System in Lubbock.

The 57-year-old pathologist was later discovered shot and stabbed inside his Lubbock home. A window was broken.

Sonnier’s girlfriend alluded to a love triangle. She told an investigator that Dixon, 48, was her ex-boyfriend but he “insisted on seeing her, even though she was dating Dr. Sonnier,” the affidavit stated.

Although it is fairly uncommon for powerful professionals to become involved in homicide cases, there have been some notable instances in Texas.

In January we reported on how a prominent Dallas plaintiff’s attorney recently pleaded guilty to murder. The lawyer, Scott Marshall, pleaded guilty on January 20, 2012, to murdering Staci Michelle Montgomery, the ex-wife of Marshall’s former law partner Bady Sassin. Marshall received a 40-year prison sentence.

Most murder charges involve individuals who know each other and often raise questions of self-defense. Also common are charges of intoxication manslaughter.

Because the stakes are so high in a murder case, it’s important to hire an experienced criminal defense attorney.

Certified by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization as a specialist in both criminal law and criminal appellate law, and with over 30 years of criminal law experience, Mick Mickelsen is a co-founder of Broden & Mickelsen, LLP in Dallas, Texas. He represents individuals charged with white-collar crimes, sex crimes, murder, drug offenses, and other serious state and federal crimes. He has handled numerous capital cases and has successfully overturned several clients’ murder convictions in post-conviction litigation. He also has worked as an adjunct professor at Southern Methodist University Dedman School of Law, teaching trial advocacy and has been a speaker at several continuing legal education (CLE) events.

Education: B.A. in English from the University of Dallas, J.D. from Georgetown University Law Center

Awards: Texas Super Lawyer since 2004, Martindale-Hubbell Rating 5.0 out of 5.0

Leadership Positions: Past Co-Chair of the Dallas Criminal Justice Committee, past Board Member of the Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association